Should judges use shaming instead of jail time when punishing criminals convicted of non-violent offenses?

The instructions said green book forget about it
2-page essay
4 body paragraphs each one should have evidence or examples.
Which means each paragraph should be supported enough.
With introduction and conclusion
See the instructions and examples more explaining about the instructions attached.It\’s an argument essay so the topic is question:
Should judges use shaming instead of jail time when punishing criminals
convicted of non-violent offenses?
Write an essay in which you take and defend a stance on that issue, with clear reasons to support your answer.
About \” shaming \”.
You may Support or not. Or mix. It\’s up to you.
The judgement should be one of three support, not support or mix.